Guess Which Ancestor is Coming to Dinner?

 

Elizabeth Steele's great-grandson Isaac Studebaker

What a wonder it would be to dine with Elizabeth Steele Studebaker, my husband’s 3^rd great-grandmother.  Elizabeth Steele continues to live through the name she has passed down to her heirs, with all six of her sons carrying her maiden name as their middle name.  Her story is discussed and speculated around the tables of many of her descendants. It conjures up tales of longing and independence on the frontier.

Elizabeth was born in Bedford County, Pennsylvania, in 1793.  Her husband, Abraham Studebaker, was born there as well.  She must have known him growing up in the same County.  He left for Miami County, Ohio, when he was only 15 years old, taking out land patents there in 1805.  It appears that he went back to Pennsylvania to marry Elizabeth in 1813. Abraham then returned to the Ohio frontier by horseback with his new bride.

The country was still wild and untamed when they came.  The troubles with Tecumseh were fresh in the minds of the settlers.  Living with relatives when they first arrived, they finally moved to their own land sometime after 1814.  Her husband built a log cabin where she raised her family of eleven children. This cabin was often used for services of the German Baptist Brethren Church, to which they belonged.  Six years after she died in 1842, he built a large brick home for his children and his new wife. 

The new wife's house

Stories are told that she must have been very lonely, living so far from her family in Bedford County, Pennsylvania.  Her niece recalled her returning to Pennsylvania alone, by horseback.  This trip would have taken more than twenty days. She left the children at home, the oldest ones, to care for the younger ones.  One story suggested her trip might have occurred in 1836 after the last child was two years old.  She is said to have stayed with her family for several months, leaving her husband and neighbors to wonder if she would return.

So many questions arise from this story.  What was her trip like? What route did she take? Did she have any of the children with her? Was she scared? Why did she stay so long?  Yes, she would be a fascinating dinner guest.   

Elizabeth's 3rd great-grandson Stephen, at their graves

First photograph from The Studebaker Family in America, 1736-1976, v. 1, by Carlock, Faust & Miller, p.188.  Second photograph from The Studebaker Family in America, 1736-1976, v. 1, by Carlock, Faust & Miller, p.57. Third photograph with permission of the photographer's son, Stephen Studebaker.